< Back to Blog
Landlord

Top Tenant Screening Services for Landlords: Finding the Best Tenant Screening Service

As a landlord, finding the right tenant is key to a good rental experience. With more rental properties, finding trustworthy tenants is more critical than ever. A good tenant screening service helps you find reliable tenants, lowering the chance of costly evictions and damage.

SmartMove says a solid tenant screening can spot evictions better, saving landlords money. With many tenant screening services out there, picking the best tenant screening service can be tough. This article will compare and review the top services, helping you choose wisely.

Key Takeaways

Why Effective Tenant Screening Is Critical for Landlords

Effective tenant screening is vital for landlords. It affects your profits and how well you manage your property. You're not just renting out a place; you're making a big financial deal with your tenants.

The Financial Impact of Problem Tenants

Problem tenants can hurt a landlord's wallet. Reports say a bad tenant can cost thousands in unpaid rent, damage, and legal fees. For example, a tenant who doesn't pay on time can lead to a costly eviction.

The average cost of eviction can range from $3,000 to $10,000. You also lose rent money while dealing with the eviction. Plus, you might have to pay more to advertise and screen new tenants.

Financial Impact Average Cost
Eviction Costs $3,000 - $10,000
Lost Rental Income Varies
Property Damage $1,000 - $5,000

Legal Protections Through Proper Screening

In addition to protecting landlords legally, thorough tenant screening aids in the search for trustworthy tenants. Verification of rental history, credit checks, and background checks are all included. This demonstrates that you have researched potential tenants.

This can be a big help if you face lawsuits or disputes.

"A well-documented tenant screening process can serve as a strong defense in the event of a fair housing complaint or other legal issues." - LeaseRunner

Building a Quality Tenant Portfolio

Good tenant screening is essential for a top-notch tenant portfolio. It helps find tenants who pay on time, take care of the property, and stay longer. This means more money for you and better property value.

Use detailed tenant screening services for credit, criminal background, and eviction history checks.

Essential Components of the Best Tenant Screening Service

To find the best tenant screening service, it's key to know what makes a good one. A top-notch service helps landlords pick the right tenants. It's all about making smart choices.

Credit History and Score Verification

Credit history and score checks are at the heart of tenant screening. They show if a person handles money well. A high credit score means they've paid bills on time.

Criminal Background Checks

Background checks for criminal activity are also crucial. They identify potentially problematic past behaviors. It's crucial to use this information in accordance with Fair Housing rules.

Eviction History Reports

Eviction history reports are important, too. They tell if someone has been kicked out before. This info helps decide if they're a good tenant.

Income and Employment Verification

Checking a tenant's income and job is a must. It makes sure they can pay rent. This involves looking at pay stubs or talking to their employer.

Component Description Importance
Credit History and Score Evaluates financial responsibility High
Criminal Background Check Identifies possible behavioral risks High
Eviction History Shows past evictions Medium
Income and Employment Verification Confirms rent payment ability High

TransUnion SmartMove: Credit Bureau-Backed Screening

For landlords, TransUnion SmartMove is a top choice for tenant screening. It's backed by TransUnion, a major credit bureau. This makes it a strong and trustworthy option.

Available Screening Packages

TransUnion SmartMove has different screening packages for landlords. These include:

These packages let landlords customize their screening to fit their needs and property type.

Pricing Structure and Value

The cost of TransUnion SmartMove's services depends on the package. Prices vary from basic credit checks to more detailed packages. For the latest prices, check the TransUnion SmartMove website or call their customer service.

Landlord Dashboard Features

The landlord dashboard is a key part of TransUnion SmartMove. It offers a place to manage tenant screening. It has features like:

These features make managing tenant screening easier and more efficient for landlords.

Pros and Cons

TransUnion SmartMove has both good and bad points.

Pros:

Cons:

Despite its drawbacks, TransUnion SmartMove is a solid choice for landlords needing a thorough tenant screening solution. Head over to this blog post to see how SmartMove compares with Rent with Clara's comprehensive digital application

RentPrep: Human-Verified Screening Reports

Landlords looking for trustworthy tenant screening should check out RentPrep. They offer reports verified by humans. This means the info is accurate and reliable, helping landlords make smart choices about tenants.

Screening Options and Verification Process

RentPrep has a variety of screening options for landlords. They review credit reports, criminal background checks, and eviction history by hand. This careful process helps spot risks and confirm applicants' trustworthiness.

The screening options include:

RentPrep prevents errors that are frequently seen in automated systems by employing people to verify data. As a result, their screening is more trustworthy.

Cost Breakdown and Comparison

RentPrep's prices are competitive, with packages for different needs. You can buy individual reports or get discounts for bulk orders.

Screening Package Cost Features
Basic $24.95 Credit report, criminal background check
Premium $39.95 Credit report, criminal background check, eviction history
Complete $49.95 Credit report, criminal background check, eviction history, income verification

Customer Support for Landlords

RentPrep provides strong customer support for landlords. You can reach out through phone, email, or online chat.

Key support features include:

Strengths and Limitations

A major benefit of RentPrep is that its human-verified reports provide landlords with reliable information. However, the price may be higher than that of automated services.

The benefits of RentPrep's service include:

In summary, RentPrep is a great choice for landlords who want thorough and reliable tenant screening.

Zillow Rental Manager: Integrated Property Management Screening

Zillow Rental Manager makes it simple for landlords to find trustworthy tenants. It's one of their tools for managing properties. Tenant screening is made easy by this service, which is integrated into the platform that landlords use.

Screening Process Integration

Zillow Rental Manager's screening is built right into its system. This lets landlords manage applications and check tenants quickly. They can see credit reports and background checks all in one place.

Report Components and Depth

The reports from Zillow Rental Manager have lots of info. They include:

This info helps landlords understand if an applicant is reliable and safe.

Cost Structure for Landlords

The screening fees charged by Zillow Rental Manager are reasonable. Typically, the applicants pay the price. This helps landlords manage applications more quickly and efficiently.

For more details on Zillow Rental Manager's pricing and features, check out their review on Landlord Studio.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Zillow Rental Manager has many benefits. It's easy to use, offers detailed reports, and saves time. But, some might find the cost of using one platform for everything a drawback.

In short, Zillow Rental Manager is a strong choice for tenant screening. It's well-integrated into their platform. Yet, landlords should think about their specific needs and compare them with other options.

MyRental by CoreLogic: Advanced Risk Assessment Tools

MyRental by CoreLogic is a great option for screening potential tenants. It provides landlords with comprehensive information about potential tenants. This aids landlords in making wise decisions.

SafeRent Score and Risk Analysis

The SafeRent Score is MyRental's key feature. It checks how reliable a tenant might be. It looks at credit history, past rentals, and more.

Key components of the SafeRent Score include:

Landlords may easily determine whether a tenant is a suitable fit with the help of this score. It aids them in choosing their renter.

Available Screening Packages

MyRental has many screening packages. They range from basic to detailed. This lets landlords pick what they need.

Package Features Price
Basic Credit report, SafeRent Score $24.90
Premium Credit report, SafeRent Score, criminal records check $37.99
Elite Credit report, SafeRent Score, criminal records check, eviction history $43.99

Pricing and Subscription Options

Prices for MyRental vary by package and reports needed. There's a discount for buying in bulk. This makes it cheaper for more reports.

For more info on MyRental by CoreLogic, visit Rental Reviews. 

Benefits and Drawbacks

MyRental has many pluses, like detailed risk checks and reports. But, some might find the prices too high, or the system too complex.

In summary, MyRental by CoreLogic is a solid choice for tenant screening. It offers deep insights and reports. While it has some downsides, its benefits make it worth considering for landlords looking to reduce risk.

Avail: All-in-One Platform with Tenant Screening

Avail is using its all-in-one platform to revolutionize rental management. Its features for tenant screening are excellent. This facilitates effective property management for landlords.

Screening Features and Report Details

Avail's tenant screening service gives landlords detailed reports. These reports help them make smart choices.

They include:

These reports help landlords understand their tenants better. This reduces risks.

Integration with Rental Management Tools

Avail's big plus is how it works with other rental tools. Landlords can manage everything from one place. This makes managing rentals easier.

Cost Structure and Free Options

Avail offers programs for each landlord, and its expenses are transparent. Full services are available for a fee. To begin with, however, there are also free options.

Pros and Cons for Independent Landlords

Independent landlords like Avail for many reasons. It offers:

But, some might find too many features or limited customization.

In summary, Avail's platform is great for landlords. It's convenient, offers full services, and is affordable.

TurboTenant: Free Landlord Platform with Applicant-Paid Screening

TurboTenant is a standout in tenant screening services. It offers a free platform for landlords and lets applicants pay for their screenings. This model is great for property managers who want to find tenants easily without extra costs.

Screening Process and Applicant Experience

TurboTenant makes it easy for both landlords and applicants. Applicants pay for their screening, which checks their credit, criminal history, and evictions. They can apply online through TurboTenant's portal.

The process is simple, making it easy for applicants to apply. This leads to more completed applications for landlords. They get a bigger pool of qualified tenants.

Report Components and Depth

TurboTenant's reports are detailed.

They cover:

These reports help landlords make smart choices. They reduce the risk of bad tenants.

Pricing Model and Value Proposition

TurboTenant's pricing is based on applicant-paid screenings. This means landlords use the platform for free. The cost for applicants is around $25 to $40, depending on the package.

This pricing is a big win for landlords. It saves them money on screening costs. It also encourages them to use the platform, as they don't pay directly.

Strengths and Limitations

Strengths:

Limitations:

Feature Description Benefit
Free Landlord Platform No costs for landlords to use the platform Reduces operational expenses
Applicant-Paid Screening Applicants cover the cost of their screening Incentivizes landlords to use the platform
Comprehensive Reports Detailed background checks on applicants Helps landlords make informed decisions

To see how TurboTenant stacks up against Clara's features, read our in-depth comparison post: Rent with Clara versus TurboTenant.

LeaseRunner: À La Carte Screening Services

LeaseRunner's à la carte screening services give landlords the freedom to pick what they need. This makes the tenant screening process more tailored and possibly cheaper.

Customizable Screening Options

LeaseRunner lets landlords choose from a variety of checks. They can pick from credit reports, criminal background checks, and eviction history. This way, landlords can create a package that fits their needs perfectly.

LeaseRunner's à la carte options let landlords focus on the most important checks for their properties.

Pay-As-You-Go Pricing Model

LeaseRunner's pricing is based on what you use. This means landlords only pay for the services they need. It's great for those with smaller properties or who don't screen tenants often.

Key benefits of this pricing model include:

Integration with Leasing Documents

LeaseRunner's service works with leasing documents. This makes the rental application process smoother. It keeps all important documents and screening results in one place.

Advantages and Disadvantages

The à la carte services offered by LeaseRunner offer numerous advantages. They provide a streamlined procedure, flexibility, and cost savings. However, there are some drawbacks to consider as well.

Advantages Disadvantages
Customizable screening options Potential for higher costs if multiple checks are selected
Pay-as-you-go pricing May require more administrative effort to manage multiple reports
Integration with leasing documents Limited to the features and services offered by LeaseRunner

In conclusion, LeaseRunner's à la carte services are a flexible and cost-effective option for landlords. By weighing the pros and cons, landlords can decide if this service fits their needs.

How to Legally Implement Your Tenant Screening Process

A good tenant screening process helps landlords choose the right tenants. It's important to make this process fair, consistent, and follow the law.

Creating Consistent Screening Criteria

Being consistent is key in tenant screening. Landlords should have clear, fair rules for all applicants. This means setting specific standards for credit scores, income, and rental history.

To make your screening criteria consistent, think about these steps:

Fair Housing Compliance Guidelines

Landlords must follow fair housing laws. These laws prevent discrimination based on many factors.

To comply, landlords should:

Following fair housing laws is not just a must; it also helps keep your reputation good and avoids expensive lawsuits.

Adverse Action Requirements

If a landlord denies an applicant, they must take adverse action.

This means:

Adverse action notices are key to a fair tenant screening process.

Documentation Best Practices

Keeping accurate records is vital for landlords.

This includes:

By following these tips, landlords can make sure their tenant screening is effective and legal.

Comparing the Best Tenant Screening Services for Different Landlord Needs

Different landlords have different needs. It's important to find the best tenant screening service for each. What works for one may not work for another, due to experience, portfolio size, and specific needs.

For New Landlords and Small Portfolios

New landlords or those with small portfolios need a service that's easy to use and affordable. TurboTenant is a great choice. It offers free platforms with screening paid by applicants, perfect for beginners.

For Experienced Property Managers

Experienced property managers need more. They need services that can handle lots of applications. MyRental by CoreLogic is a good pick. It has advanced tools and detailed reports.

"Advanced screening tools are key for experienced managers to reduce risk and find better tenants."

For Large Multi-Property Operations

Landlords with many properties need scalable services. Avail is a top choice. It offers a platform that includes tenant screening, ideal for big operations.

Service Scalability Integration
Avail High Excellent
MyRental Medium Good
TurboTenant Low Fair

Cost vs. Comprehensiveness Comparison

Choosing a tenant screening service means balancing cost and report depth. More detailed reports might cost more. But they offer insights that help make better decisions.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Rental Business

Choosing the best tenant screening service is key to your rental business's success. There are many options out there. It's important to pick one that meets your specific needs and goals.

Think about what checks are most important for your business. This could be credit history, criminal background, or eviction history. Also, check the pricing to make sure it fits your budget.

The right service can help you find trustworthy tenants. It can also lower the risk of property damage and legal problems. By using a thorough screening process, you can keep your rental income safe and build a good reputation.

What's best for your rental business will depend on your unique needs and priorities. Do your research and compare different services. Don't be afraid to ask providers for more details about what they offer.

Read Articles

Top Tenant Screening Services for Landlords: Finding the Best Tenant Screening Service

Learn more→

The True Cost of Renting

Discover all rental costs beyond monthly rent. From application fees to utilities, learn what renters need to budget for success.

Learn more→

How to Negotiate Rent and Save Money on Your Lease

Learn how to negotiate rent with confidence. From timing tips to effective strategies, our guide helps renters secure fair rates and save money.

Learn more→

Simplify Renting with Clara

< Back to Blog